View Our Catalog

Join Our E-Mail List

What's New

Sign Language Studies

American Annals of the Deaf

Press Home

Deaf Education in America: Voices of Children from Inclusion Settings

Previous Page

Next Page


Kyle
   If I didnít understand the work we were doing, like if I didnít understand the directions, Iíd sometimes ask the interpreter,
   and if the interpreter didnít know what to do, then Iíd ask the teacher. I had an interpreter in the classroom, but I didnít
   like having to look back and forth between the interpreter and the other stuff happening in the classroom.

Tyler
   If I donít understand a question in class, the interpreter will explain it to me. But a hearing school needs a strong hearing
   support teacher to teach deaf students.

Jasmine
   Hearing teachers try to explain, they lecture . . . but at the deaf school they make eye contact. We will learn by doing first
   and then write about it, which is easy because we just experienced it. Hearing people can just talk about it and then start
   writing. In deaf school we know what to write because first we see, touch, and manipulate things. Deaf people are visual
   learners, and we need to touch and manipulate to learn, and if you have questions you can ask and get immediate
   responses. Hearing people are more auditory learners and can learn just by hearing. Itís hard for deaf people in hearing
   schools. They donít give many visual examples in hearing schools. You just get a paper and you are left wondering how to
   answer . . . so either you copy from someone else or you fail.
      If I had my way, I wouldnít want to have an interpreter. Just teach me directly in ASL.

Julie
   I struggle to understand some of the teachers. The hearing students do OK with the teachers, but for a deaf student, it is
   different; it is harder. The homework is based on written paragraphs, and I donít always understand. The teacher doesnít
   use many physical examples; instead, it is mostly writing on the board and lecturing. I struggle with that.
      Middle school was more laid back. We had games and activities. It seemed we had more time to learn things. But in
   high school, class time is only lectures and reading. I canít understand it as well. Itís really tedious and boring. I prefer
   seeing physical demonstrations. I donít like being limited to lectures and notes, and so I am looking forward to attending a
   deaf school next year. I think Iíve had my fill of mainstreaming in hearing schools.
      If I donít understand something, Iíll ask the interpreter to help explain things. Like the teacher hands out the homework,
   and if I donít understand the written directions on the homework, I ask the interpreter, and she explains it. That way I
   know which part of the book to use to find the answers. If I donít understand, then I donít ask the teacher; Iíll ask the
   interpreter.

Sam
   I like going to a hearing school. I feel I have gotten a good education there. And, Iíve learned how to live in the hearing
   culture.

The experience of receiving an interpreted education seems to be significantly different from the experience of receiving a direct education. Zackís frustration with the pace of interpreting suggests a negative impact on his ability to finish his work on time. Not only does he miss recess, but he also feels singled out, which increases his feelings of embarrassment. Zack experiences ďexposure embarrassment,Ē a feeling that comes when children are aware that they have become the object of other peoplesí attention. For Zack, the pain of embarrassment is constant while in the hearing classroom. In fact, the themes of embarrassment, feeling different, and feeling alienated are strong throughout Zackís interview.

Kyle emphasized another frustration of trying to learn through an interpreter. He explains that he didnít like looking between the interpreter and the ďother stuff happening in the classroom.Ē Other students also voiced this frustration, noting a desire on their part to read the teacherís expression and body language, while having access to the message. Jasmine also understands this frustration and declares that direct instruction is better because ďif you have questions you can ask and get immediate responses.Ē

Jasmine and Julie both commented that the way deaf students learn is not conducive to the way hearing students are taught. Jasmine speaks of the need for deaf students to see, touch, and manipulate things before writing about them. Without this support, she feels her only alternative is to copy from someone else or to fail. Julie also insists that deaf students are more visual learners and benefit from visual demonstrations, rather than lectures and notes. She directly links her declining success in the classroom between middle school and high school to the change in teaching methodsófrom visual and tactile learning to lectures and copying notes.

Several of the students mentioned they had difficulty with written instructions. Julie confesses that she does not understand the homework, which is often based on written paragraphs. Kyle and Tyler also mentioned not understanding directions. In order to appropriately accommodate deaf students, the deaf education teachers need to be active in adapting homework, tests, and projects to make them accessible to the deaf student. Tyler acknowledged this need for a strong deaf education teacher, as well.

When asked ďWho do you ask when you donít understand?Ē some deaf students explained that they turn to the interpreter to find out what to do, but if the interpreter does not know, they might ask the teacher. Perhaps their reluctance to ask the teacher stems from their embarrassment at having a low reading level and not understanding. However, it may also reflect their view of the interpreter as the intermediary between them and the hearing world.


Previous Page

Next Page